Edwardsville IL Homes for Sale and Real Estate

The Ultimate Answer to the Zillow Zestimate

 

I get questions very often about the accuracy of the Zillow Zestimate. (For those of you saying, "huh?" right now, Zillow is a popular real estate website which gathers information from a variety of public sources to produce an estimate of property value they call a "Zestimate.")

Sellers worry that their listing price looks off in comparison.  Buyers wonder why a home is listed higher than the Zestimate and try to lowball properly priced sellers based on this number. 

My blogging colleague, Phil, in Westchester County, NY, has just written about this issue and I think he did it so well that I want to share it with my readers. What goes for him in NY, goes for me here on the middle coast in St. Louis' Illinois suburbs.

Here's the best piece of wisdom to take away from Phil's reporting: "If the Zestimate is the starting point...the licensed professional is the "Zactimate."

Phil goes on to explain:  "It makes sense. There is no valuation algorithm that can smell a pet or recognize 1970 wood panelling in the living room. There is no formula to judge good or bad staging, a neighbor's yard with a car on blocks, or a rehab job that transforms a ho-hum place into a palace. Indeed, a Zestimate cannot drive the client around in its car, and it is...a starting point."

"The final word, the best source of predicting how the market will behave about a property is a living, breathing experienced licensee on the ground who can walk in the living room and look out the window. The Zestimate is an estimate. Period. It doesn't live, work, drive through, or close deals ...I am the Zactimate..."

Thank you for putting it together in an eloquent and understandable way, Phil. Please read on to see his complete post:

 

Perhaps no phenomenon in real estate is as much of a lightning rod for strong opinions as the Zillow Zestimate. Most agents I speak with hate it; I have had instances where looking it up has helped a deal and I have had clients walk from a deal because of it. The Zillow Zestimate has been the reason for sellers to feel under-priced or under-bid, and it has been invoked by buyers as the reason that they feel they overbid on a home. I once got so exasperated that I asked a client if a Zestimate ever drove them around Westchester County like I did when they used it to justify an unrealistic offer.

As you might guess, I have never associated the Zestimate with the easy button. 

Yet today, I had an epiphany about the Zestimate with the great help of Zillow's outreach manager, Brad Andersohn. Brad's stature in my eyes is impossible to compromise; his credibility is beyond questioning. The Zestimate, Brad said as he spoke to a group of colleagues, is a starting point. Not an ending point. 

Allow me to back up just a moment. Zillow's own disclosure on their front page about Zestimate accuracy is surprisingly candid. In my own New York market, the average margin of error of the Zillow Zestimate is 11.6%. They aren't trying to be something they are not. 

Back to Brad- If the Zestimate is the starting point, he said, the licensed professional is the "Zactimate." What a way of putting it. 

It makes sense. There is no valuation algorithm that can smell a pet or recognize 1970 wood panelling in the living room. There is no formula to judge good or bad staging, a neighbor's yard with a car on blocks, or a rehab job that transforms a ho-hum place into a palace. Indeed, a Zestimate cannot drive the client around in its car, and it is exactly what Brad says: a starting point. 

The final word, the best source of predicting how the market will behave about a property is a living, breathing experienced licensee on the ground who can walk in the living room and look out the window. The Zestimate is an estimate. Period. It doesn't live, work, drive through, or close deals in Westchester County. That's what I do. As a broker who can sit at your kitchen table with my laptop logged onto the MLS and speak with authority on the town's market activity (homes I myself often walked through and even sold myself), I am the Zactimate. In this context, there is peace at the water hole. I thank Brad for stating it so eloquently. 

Subscribe to J. Philip's Real Estate Blog by Email

Active Rain members-Feed your mind.    

  • We Are Westchester County & Metro New York Real Estate. Reach Phil at (914) 723-8900.
  • J. Philip Faranda, Broker-owner, J. Philip Real Estate, LLC. Vice President, Empire Access Multiple Listing Service. 
  • I am one of New York's premier short sale REALTORS, serving Westchester, the Hudson Valley & Metropolitan New York.
  • Free MLS Search! Register for a Free Listingbook account and search the MLS like an agent. 
  • I am hiring agents. We offer outstanding support, marketing resources, and pasta. 
             

All content/images, unless noted, are the property of J. Philip Faranda & may not be used without permission

Enjoy life in the (618) area code in Southwestern Illinois, St. Louis' Illinois suburbs. SEARCH FOR HOMES HERE.

 

LIKE MY BLOG? PLEASE SUBSCRIBE HERE.

I help good people buy and sell good homes in St. Louis' Illinois suburbs, with special emphasis on the Metro East communities of Edwardsville, Glen Carbon, Maryville, Collinsville, Troy and surrounding areas in Madison County, Illinois.

Are you a teacher, firefighter, law enforcement officer, medical professional or active duty or retired military? Then ask me about Homes for Heroes, offering substantial savings on home purchases. Learn more at Homes For Heroes.

For more information or to search for homes, visit my sites at NancyMilton.com618Life.com, or GoshenRealtyGroup.com or send an email to me at Nancy@GoshenRealtyGroup.com. Text or call Nancy Milton Holtzscher, your Edwardsville Realtor, at 618-791-8007 any time.

REMAX Preferred Partners is located at One 157 Center, Edwardsville, IL 62025, 618-791-8007 (direct) 618-655-1188 (office). We're easy to find on IL-157 in Edwardsville between Pasta House Co. and Shenanigans. Each office is independently owned and operated.

Comment balloon 5 commentsNancy Milton Holtzscher • April 06 2011 11:43AM
The Ultimate Answer to the Zillow Zestimate
share
I get questions very often about the accuracy of the Zillow Zestimate. (For those of you saying, "huh? " right now, Zillow is a popular real estate website which gathers information from a variety of public sources to produce an… more
Selling Your Home? There's Only One Good Way to Reach Younger Buyers…
share
Selling Your Home? There's Only One Good Way to Reach Younger Buyers Today -- By Texting. This revelation about the necessity of texting occurred to me a number of years ago when I was frustrated with trying to reach my daughter the old… more
Edwardsville Residents: Big Trash Pickup is the Week of April 4, 2011
share
Edwardsville Residents: Big Trash Pickup is the Week of April 4, 2011. Got junk? Then Edwardsville's spring big trash pickup can give you a place to put it. The week of April 4, on your regular trash day, you can kick your large,… more
Hey Edwardsville Realtor: How Long Do I Have to Wait After a…
share
Hey, Edwardsville Realtor: How Long Do I Have to Wait After a Foreclosure, Bankruptcy or Short Sale Before I Can Get Another Home Loan? I get a lot of questions like this. Potential buyers want to know how long they will have to stay out of… more
Homes for Sale in Edwardsville's Dunlap Lake Neighborhood
share
Homes for Sale in Edwardsville's Dunlap Lake Neighborhood Lake living in Edwardsville, Illinois? Yes, you can be close to town and still enjoy all the benefits of living on or near a beautiful lake. Established in 1939, the Dunlap Lake… more
Bright, clean and open - 402 Bluebird Troy, IL
share
Call agent for more info: Nancy Milton & Kristina Pratt at 618-791-8007 Or Text for more info: Text "129572" To 79564 &… more
Live Large at Dunlap Lake! 435 W Lake Drive, Edwardsville
share
Call agent for more info: Nancy Milton & Kristina Pratt at 618-791-8007 Or Text for more info: Text "129496" To 79564 &… more
5 Cedar Mill, Troy - Immaculate One-Owner Ranch
share
Call agent for more info: Nancy Milton & Kristina Pratt at 618-791-8007 Or Text for more info: Text "129353" To 79564 &… more
The Most Expensive Homes in St. Louis' Illinois Metro East Suburbs:…
share
I know you're sitting there right now, reading real estate blogs and wondering about the most expensive homes in St. Louis' Illinois suburbs -- where are they, what are their listing prices and what do they look like inside? Of course you are. &… more
Good Things Come to Those Who Wait: Buying and Selling Edwardsville…
share
BUYING AND SELLING EDWARDSVILLE AREA SHORT SALES We get a lot of questions about short sales. From the basics, "What is a short sale? " To the unanswerable, "Why does it take so long for the bank to approve my short sale? " &… more